• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Scotty's on Sheridan

At Scotty's on Sheridan, nestled in Highwood's vibrant restaurant scene, the charm of a classic cocktail bar meets the innovation of New American cuisine. Our story is one of community and culinary excellence, where every dish reflects a commitment to quality. From the savory Shrimp de Jonghe to fresh Mediterranean power bowls, each plate tells a story of flavor and creativity. Our inviting atmosphere, enhanced by attentive service, creates the perfect backdrop for gatherings, be it a casual dinner with friends or a family celebration. Join us for an unforgettable dining experience that truly captures the spirit of our neighborhood.

Scotty's on Sheridan: Reviews & Ratings

Mit M.
Mit M.

Very nice experience from service to food. Fish was really good and dessert was fantastic. If you are looking for a nice quiet place for a great dinner check this place out. Oh the server was very attentive and made the experience pleasant. Thank you and see you again this week.

Priscilla S.
Priscilla S.

Our group of 6 dined on Friday night. The dining room was busy, but we had great service and our dinners were excellent.

Paul S.
Paul S.

Always consistently solid. The entrees hit the mark. Their pizza is maybe the weakest link but other entrees are great.

Bob C.
Bob C.

Highly recommended Food was fantastic Service was fantastic Atmosphere old school and lovely Nestled on the north end of Highwood's restaurant row on Sheridan road you couldn't ask for a nicer dining experience A bit pricey BUT don't let that stop you as the old saying goes ; You get what you pay for From appetizers which we had the calamari to the main course , I had the Francesco salmon , like I said food was amazing and let's not forget the dessert which was oh so good. I had a taste of both coconut cake and key lime pie. This was a wonderful family event and we look forward to our next visit Thanks guys !

Doug C.
Doug C.

I really like this place. Seated immediately for a 5pm Sunday reservation, we were greeted by a wonderful server who never disappointed. Orders taken promptly, drinks refilled and questions answered. The food was delicious, from fish to steak to burger(a tad slow receiving our food but that really wasn't a problem and it happens in most restaurants we've visited recently). Scotty's is relatively small and filled up quickly with what seemed like regulars, and the noise level increased as well...but that's to be expected in a friendly neighborhood joint. We've been disappointed by a couple of other restaurants in Highwood but recommend this one without question.

Cyndi K.
Cyndi K.

We are from out of state and had the most wonderful experience at Scottie's! The bar was so cozy to begin our evening with and the dining room equally wonderful. The service was warm and welcoming; everyone! We took our servers suggestions for ordering our food and she was spot on! Delicious with a beautiful presentation. I imagine we couldn't have gone wrong no matter what we ordered because it all looked amazing. I highly recommend Scottie's!

Space Cowboy G.
Space Cowboy G.

We arrived a little after 5:00 PM. They just opened. We had no reservation and chose to sit at the bar. The early crowd appeared to be the Seniors who were all to familiar with Scotty. Warm wishes of HNY and conversations were everywhere. The bar service was excellent. We enjoyed a wedge salad which was divided and chopped (delicious). Next we shared a pizza. Cooked perfectly, topped with spinach. The pizza is thin and crispy. Desert was a warm brownie a-la mode with walnuts and cinnamon. You wouldn't think much, seeing this place from the road. Scotty's sits in the middle of a strip mall. The interior however, is cozy, quiet, with just enough light. The Wine and Spirits terrific. Bonus: The wine is a generous pour. We will definitely be back. Well done Scotty.

Lisa M.
Lisa M.

Another great Bleu cheese burger! But the raves go to their Creme Burlee w/ fruit. THE best dessert! Wait time for take out on a Saturday night was quick & place was packed. Thank you!

Jan M.
Jan M.

We've come here several times over the years, always sitting in the stylish and comfortable bar. The service and food are consistently excellent. On this visit we started with cocktails, which are always perfectly made. The bread and giardiniera go well with anything! We also ordered a bottle of Cabernet for dinner. The very cool, yet unassuming host, Scotty makes sure that everyone is well attended to. He has the respect of his staff as well as the patrons, who primarily consist of happy regulars. All staff members are professional and helpful. My husband started with a very good Clam Chowder. I chose the salad special of greens, dried cherries, walnuts, crumbled blue cheese and vinaigrette dressing. I would be happy having that salad every day! I was glad to have a choice of two sizes of the Filet entrée and picked the 4 oz size. I still had leftovers! The filet, mashed potatoes and green beans almandine were all excellent! The ribs here are always a favorite and one of us usually has to order them, sometimes for takeout - from the Vernon Hills location which is closer to home. We wish we lived closer!

Location

Discover Scotty's on Sheridan, a captivating culinary destination nestled on the north end of Highwood's restaurant row at 810 Sheridan Rd. This charming cocktail bar and New American eatery invites you to indulge in a delightful dining experience, seamlessly blending a classy ambiance with an approachable, casual vibe—perfect for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings.

At Scotty's, you'll find a diverse menu that showcases mouthwatering dishes, all crafted with care. Start your culinary journey with appetizers like the Hannah's Crab Cakes or the savory Shrimp de Jonghe, baked to perfection and bursting with flavor. The Crostinis with smashed avocado and fresh mozzarella, drizzled with balsamic glaze, make for an excellent shareable treat, setting the stage for the delightful entrees to follow.

For those craving a hearty meal, the burger offerings, such as the Digman Cheeseburger and BBQ Bacon Burger, promise to satisfy even the most discerning palates. Diners rave about the consistent quality of the dishes here, with many noting the superb service that enhances the overall experience. Customers appreciate the attention to detail and the welcoming atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for family dinners or friend gatherings.

  • Reservations Available: Ideal for planning special nights out.
  • Outdoor Seating: Savor your meal in the fresh air during pleasant weather.
  • Full Bar: Enjoy a selection of crafted cocktails to complement your meal.
  • Good for Kids: A family-friendly environment that caters to younger diners.

The ambiance at Scotty's on Sheridan warrants special mention. With moderate noise levels and a hint of old-school charm, it's the kind of place where laughter flows as freely as the drinks. While the atmosphere fills up quickly, especially on busy nights like Saturday, this buzz only adds to the warmth of the experience. Patrons often describe it as a friendly neighborhood joint, where local favorites feel like home.

Don't miss the chance to treat yourself to dessert, where options like coconut cake and key lime pie linger in your memory long after the final bite. It's a reminder that at Scotty's, every meal is not just about food, but about creating delightful moments with loved ones.

In conclusion, whether you're a local or just passing through Highwood, Scotty's on Sheridan is a must-visit culinary haven that guarantees a remarkable dining experience steeped in flavor, warmth, and conviviality. With the enticing menu, attentive service, and delightful atmosphere, this restaurant undoubtedly stands out as a gem in the heart of the community.